One of the more exotic technologies for tracking deeply submerged submarines consists of using a satellite based radar to measure the tiny elevation of the water surface of the ocean above an otherwise well hidden and silently moving submarine. Some less exotic techniques including detecting wakes, tiny differences in water temperatures, magnetic fluctuations and many other “indirect” methods. What I propose to do today is something similar: to try to look at some possible signals of what might be happening hidden deep inside the Russian security establishment.
Doku Umarov |
As some of you might have recalled, I have regularly covered what I saw as a government campaign to defund, “reform” (read: shut down) and otherwise weaken the Russian elite military forces. A Spetsnaz brigade was dismantled, the military intelligence service (GRU) was almost reduced to a Department of the General Staff, the 106th Airborne Division came close to being simply eliminated, and a number of top officers were either rather “mysteriously died” or resigned. Things got totally out of control when the Airborne Forces almost officially demanded the sacking of Defense Minister Serdyukov.
Magomedali Vagabov |
And then things suddenly seemed to cool down, and an eerie silence covered this entire “front”. There are now some signs that things have actually begun to change.
First, the Russian security services have embarked on a major campaign to capture or eliminate the leaders of the Wahabi underground in the Caucasus.
Even before the bombing of the Domodedovo airport in Moscow several top leaders of the Wahabi underground in the Caucasus (such as Magometali Vagabov) were killed in the course of several special operations. Following the Domodedovo bombing (which was officially claimed by the self-styled “First Emir of the Emirate of the Caucasus” Doku Umarov) the campaign to track
Abdullah Kurd |
down and kill the Wahabi leaders suddenly intensified and achieved major successes. Many top officials of the Wahabi insurgency were killed including “Moganned” (a Saudi national), “Abdullah Kurd” (a Turkish national), Israpil Validjanov, Asker Djapuev and even Astemir Mimishev – the assassin of the Mufti of the Kabardino-Balkar Republic. All of them were killed in the time period between April and May of this year.
The one still not caught, although his death has been announced many times only to be proven wrong is Doku Umarov himself. Umarov, arguably the very last “historical” leader of the Chechen insurgency alive, has skillfully managed to escape many times from some very close calls, but there is no doubt in my mind that the noose around him is now extremely tight and that he will be killed very soon.
Asker Djapuev |
As for the insurgency itself, it is reduced to two basic types of operations: high visibility “symbolic” terrorist attacks such as the one in Domodedovo or small, local level, assassinations of junior policemen and murders of “collaborators”. The single best indicator of the real capabilities of the insurgency is that it is handled only by Ministry of Internal Affairs forces and not by the military (the exception being, of course, the killing of top level commanders which is typically a join effort of the FSB and the GRU with logistical support from local police forces).
Astemir Mamishev |
Bottom line: the insurgency has been defeated, most of its leaders are dead, and the scope and nature of Wahabi terrorism in the Caucasus and south Russia has been brought down to something similar to what the IRA was in the years preceding the Good Friday Agreement.
Of course, there is a Presidential election coming up in Russia and Medvedev has been challenged for many of his policies (betrayal of Iran, his “reforms” of the military, Russia’s vote in the UN on Libya and many others) and, just like Obama, he needs to market himself as a “strong leader”. This is particularly true considering that Prime Minister Putin is far more popular than Medvedev.
Moganned |
There are also signs that Medvedev is openly courting elite Russian military forces. First, there was the absolutely unprecedented move to award the Order of Kutuzov to the 45th Independent Special Operations Airbore Regiment as a whole (rather than to one individual). Not only that, but this year the 45th Independent Special Operations Airborne Regiment was invited to the Victory Parade on Red Square.
Something even more amazing happened on the same day: for the first time ever the traditionally super-secret GRU Spetsnaz forces were also represented during the Victory Day lead by a Spetsnaz Colonel who was identified by name (!). Considering the fact that Spetsnaz GRU forces are still normally
Israpil Validzhanov |
under order never to even show their faces, having them participate in a parade transmitted worldwide is an absolutely amazing, I would say earth-shattering, departure from the usual practice.
Medvedev also showed his support for the Special Forces of the Internal Ministry during a visit to the HQ of the “Rys'” Spetsnaz unit which included a lengthy conversation with the officers of this elite unit.
Clearly Medvedev is going out of his way to make all the political moves needed to show his support for the previously neglected security forces. His efforts actually go beyond the symbolic.
Spetsnaz GRU sniper in Ossetia |
The 106th Guard Airborne division has recently received a lot of high tech gear including UAVs, reconnaissance vehicles and ATV, top of the line night vision gear, encryption communications, advanced computerized command and control networks, etc. A division which was almost disbanded is now receiving lavish care from the Kremlin.
Of course, this could all be a short lived, one-time, effort in order to achieve some political gains. But this might also signal that Medvedev has finally accepted the fact that he cannot indefinitely oppose the security establishment and that a typically Russian backstage deal was made between the Kremlin and the security and key military forces. I am inclined to believe that the latter is true.
45 Airborne Spetsnaz on Victory Day |
Whatever may be the case, this is clearly good news for Russia in general and for the Caucasus in particular. After two decades of absolute horror and chaos, there is a least a non-irrelevant possibility that some normalization and recovery might take place. The combined action of the security forces and the Kremlin’s campaign to support non-Wahabi Islam are slowly bringing about some results. What is now needed is another double struggle: to bring in economic growth to the Caucasus and a merciless crackdown at the local corruption which is absolutely horrendous, even by Russian standards.
Spetsnaz “Rys'” officer |
Medvedev has embarked on a massive campaign to fight corruption in Russia. This campaign is centered on two mains tracks: a massive overhaul of the hideously corrupt and incompetent police force combined with an equally ferocious crackdown on corrupt government officials. The faces of sacked police generals are now paraded on TV on an almost daily basis and the Kremlin is using the crafty pretext of a “re-attestation” of *all* the Internal Ministry official (from the rank and file to the very top commanders) to sack anybody who is perceived as corrupt or incompetent. The Russian public in understandably viewing all this with a lot of skepticism, or even cynicism, and only time will show if all these efforts are for real or not. The key test, in my opinion, will be if the Kremlin will be willing (and able) crackdown on the all-powerful Mafia and gangs of thugs which have prospered in the Caucasus for many decades.
Spetsnaz GRU Col. Tkachuk on Victory Day |
The problem of the Wahabi insurgency cannot be separated from the problem of the south Russian mob – the two are twin brothers, closely linked at many levels. For example, one of the reasons why only central “elite” Spetsnaz forces have been able to eliminate so many Wahabi leaders is not that such operations require an amazing amount of military skills, but simply because the central Spetsnaz forces have no connections to the local mob or the local police (which, for all practical purposes is one and the same).
This is an ambitious multi-tired program for sure, but one which is vital for the stability and security of all of Russia. If it takes a looming Presidential election to finally make it happen, then this is a good thing.
The Saker
Russians will fail too if they think they can make a local population of Muslims kneel in humble obedience if they apply brutal enough force, because popular movements only grow with persecution, and not diminish, if they think the moral high ground has been abandoned by the perceived foreign force trying to put a boot on the neck of a local majority. It may work with popular support for the crackdown, and disgust for the terrorists, even with brutal tactics, but with a cultural majority against you, and if you are perceived as hostile and cruel and immoral force, ask the French how well that worked for them in Algeria.
@oldman:Russians will fail too if they think they can make a local population of Muslims kneel in humble obedience if they apply brutal enough force,
I fully agree with you, but I don’t I have ever suggested that this was the policy. The vast majority of Muslims in the Caucasus are not Wahabis and, if you read my article carefully, you will notice that I refer to one of the Wahabi insurgents who actually killed the Mufti of the Kabardino-Balkar republic. In fact, Medvedev may be all sort of bad things, but he has put a GREAT deal of efforts into protecting and integrating the Russian Muslims into the Russian society. Recently, a couple of Russian nationalists who murdered a lawyer who had been working on human rights abuses in Chechnia by Russian forces were given very long prison sentences. When a group of Caucasians killed a Russian soccer fan and the other supporters of the same soccer club wanted to riot, the police beat them back rather brutally. To say that the Kremlin is somehow trying to “make a local population of Muslims kneel in humble obedience” is factually incorrect and misses the point of what the Kremlin wants.
HOWEVER,
It is clearly a fact that the Kremlin offers the Wahabi insurgents only two options: put down your arms or be killed. That is an option which I fully support and which I believe most Muslims in Russia and even in the Caucasus also support. Nobody, and I mean *nobody* wants a return to the horrors of the years of the “Independent Chechen Republic of Ichkeria”, least of all the Chechens themselves. BTW – the Chechens might not like the Russian puppet thug in power now (Ramzan Kadyrov), but they also know that no positive change will happen through a continuation of the insurgency. Been there, done that. Never again.
Make no mistake, oldman, Russia is fighting a very small minority of Wahabi crazies and ruthless mobsters. Not “Muslims” or Islam itself.
Cheers!
The Saker
@oldman: one more thing: it would be an assumption to confliate “Muslim” with Chechia or even with the entire Caucasus. There are something in the range of 30’000’000 (that is 30 millions!) Muslims in Russia making Islam the 2nd most practiced religion in Russia. Мost Russian Muslims are not from the Caucasus at all, but Tatars, Bashkirs and Kirghiz. So the wars in the Caucasus are not about religion even if one side, the Chechen insurgents, claim to be acting to create an Islamic Emirate in the Caucasus (nevermind that not all the Caucasian people are Muslims, that Wahabism has no basis there at all, and that most Chechens are traditionally Sufis). Again, this is not about “Muslims kneeling” but about Russia as a country and the Caucasus as a region fighting for their survival. This is about the reality that to allow any part of this region to become a Wahabistan would destabilize an already volatile region. This is why Russian forces defended the Tadjik borders when the Taliban attempted to penetrate Tadjikistan and impose their brand of Islam on the country.
Of course, there ARE tensions between Muslims and non-Muslims in Russia, mostly fed by loud nationalist on both sides, but the state as such has shown exactly *ZERO* inclination to side with the Slavic or Orthodox majority. Finally, consider this: only about 1% of all Russias are what one could call practicing Orthodox Christians. The figures for the Muslims might be higher, but not by much. Sadly, ALL the peoples of the former Soviet Union were”re-educated” by the atheist Marxists propaganda and only a minority is now truly committed to its faith, though these numbers are slowly growing, no doubt.
Anyway, long speech just to tell you that “Muslim” and “Chechen Wahabi” are two VERY different things.
Cheers!
Great article, Saker. It’s very hard to find information on this subject, and for me it’s very interesting. Thanks for sharing.
@Carlo: you are more than welcome. Yes, information on this topic is hard to come by and, until recently, all the main actors were quite literally going out of their way not to be noticed. This is also one of the reasons I decided to collect some photos and show the faces of the people involved (I always had the feeling that faces show a lot).
It is amazing at how little attention is paid to this conflict even though the stability of a HUGE strategic zone is directly dependent on it. The Wahabis are now fighting on all fronts, from Bahrain to Chechnya, from Pakistan to Algeria and from Yemen to the UK. Yet somehow, either we have hysterical Muslim-haters who conflate them with Islam in general (which is absolutely ignorant and stupid), or we have the Muslim world somehow uncomfortable with the entire topic and simply saying nothing about it.
One example, but an oh so telling one:
Carlo, did you notice that Hezbollah did not comment by a SINGLE WORD the alleged killing of Osama Bin Laden. I checked all their websites on a daily basis, I checked the Lebanese press, I checked the Iranian press, I even emailed a friend in Lebanon and in reply *silence*.
Even Hezbollah, the most sophisticated, educated and enlightened Islamic political movement out there simply does not have the stomach to take the political risk of saying anything about OBL’s assassination.
The same goes for Chechnia. When the Wahabis murder Bahraini Shia Hezbollah speaks up. When Wahabis kill Dagestani Sufis, Hezbollah looks the other way. If the Iranians could intervene to protect the Bahrainis Hezbollah would, no doubt, approve, but if the Russians intervene in Dagestan – Hezbolllah will look the other way lest it is suspected of siding with the infidels against the faithful.
As I said – this is a “right or wrong – my umma” mindset which I do not expect to change anytime soon. The best we can do as Christians is not to reciprocate in kind and NOT to side with any so-called “Christian” against any Muslim in a knee-jerk reaction.
Cheers!
Well, the Iranians are very conscious of the fact that bin Laden was (probably until his death) a US agent:
http://english.farsnews.com/newstext.php?nn=9002121340
Anyway, in the general you are (unfortunately) right. Genuinely Muslim and Christian liberation movements would benefit a lot from cooperation, while the fight against fanaticism is of direct interest to every religion.
@VINEYARDSAKER:
I do not believe you are an Orthodox Christian.
What nonsense in regards to Muslim and non-Muslim relations in Russia.
Russian negative response towards Muslims is due to the fact that the international mainstream Muslims community and organisations actively funded and promoted the most radical revolutionary Muslim ideology to create separate Muslim communities in Russia financed to the tune of billions actively hostile to the Russian state during the 90’s and continuing to the present.
Traditional Muslim leadership in Russia is going against the mainstream Muslim consensus.
British/US instituted “shock therapy” economic policies main objective was to decrease the ethnic Russian population of Russia coupled with the massive distribution of drugs, porn, prostitution, alcohol etc and change the demographic nature of Russia increasing its Muslim population and making it ripe for civil conflict.
And this cop out use of Wahabbism is a poor excuse to simply just label Islamic terrorism under this banner as the Bosnian terror regime since the 80’s and 90’s main avenue of supports was from Iran and the Chechens main avenue of support derives from Turkey and countries with Chechen ancestry in the Mid East like Jordan.
It is the Muslims and the Chechens that started the genocide against Russian and Orthodox Christianity not the phoney one championed by their western terrorist sponsors from the offices of Ruder and Fin which now even The Washington Post has stated the death toll of both conflicts from both sides at 50,000 which those contributed to actual military combat death is unknown.
The only way Russia can actually stop terrorism in the North Caucasus and the Eurasian sphere is to expose Chechnya is a network war created and organised from its inception by foreign powers mainly Britain, US, France, Germany, Turkey and Saudi Arabia and the key to that is 9/11.
If there goal was simply independence they would not have signed contracts with British establishment businesses and organising MI6 terrorist fronts to be established in Chechnya nor would they have expanded the Chechen terrorist/organised crime network to other CIA linked movements like the KLA and the Taliban in Afghanistan.
This is just used as a front to annex neighbouring Dagestan, control the Caspian oil basin and to destabilise Russia.
And don’t give me that moderate and radical BS as any fool can clearly see they are two signs of the same coin and work together.
The conflict in Chechnya is a puppet proxy war supported by fascist Turks and others so the practise of kow towing to Chechens and working against the interest of ethnic Russian like negating the Chechen lead genocide has not and will not work.
Like the Chechen’s Russia should expand the war overseas and takes the war to the heart of their operations in Turkey eliminate the leaders in the most violent and crude manner.
http://theriseofrussia.blogspot.com/2009/02/i-have-always-said-that-brutal-war-in.html
And this bullshit its all the Saudi Wahabbism nonsense you drone on about is counter to the actual facts.
What do you make of Zhirinovsky’s warnings in this interview:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aHfZBQyr2Fs&feature=email
Also, can you vouch for the fact that the translation is accurate? Or is it a hoax.
Kind Regards,
AA
@АА: the translation is fine, but I beg you not to take ANYTYING Zhirik (as he is known in Russia) says seriously. He is a buffoon, a court jester for the Kremlin, he has said so many idiotic, outrageous and false things in his political career that nobody takes the men seriously.
Mind you – I like to watch him on TV shows as I do find him hilarious at times. Once in parliament he held a hearing on the rehabilitation use of cruse-language (мат) “potty words” which he considers an integral part of the Russian culture.
Don’t pay any attention to anything he says. Really. Unless you are like me and want to have a good laugh.
A couple of years ago Zhirik threatened the USA with, I kid you not, changing the rotational axis of the world to destroy the North American continent. He also predicted that Saddam’s soldiers would destroy the US military and that the Russian emigres in the USA would elect their own – Russian – president of the USA.
It is funny, I agree, but please don’t ever take this clown seriously.
Cheers!
The Saker
VINEYARDSAKER, you forgot to mention the death of Supyan Abdullayev, Doku Umarov’s deputy in late March, the same strike that almost killed Umarov himself. This whole new offensive did not start this year of course. It started with the meticulous operation of June of last year in 2010, when FSB troops captured Akhmed Yevloyev, a.k.a Emir Magas, the over all military emir of the Caucasus Emirate. Doku Umarov may be the Emir, but Magas was the military chief. And from what I can gather a former Police Officer for the Interior Ministry of Ingushetia in the 1990’s. Not just another thugh with a uniform. He also orhstrated the highly successful Nazran raid of 2004. In any case the capture of Magas alive has most likely given the Russians a treasure trove of intelligence on the Emirate’s military infrastructure/apparatus. Muhannad was Magas’ deputy he probably got betrayed by Magas under duress. The overall military emir would also have a good knowledge of safe houses, auxilary support personnel and hideouts in the forests. What they need to do now is go on the hunt again for another capture, not just kills. Aslanbek Vadalov would be a great capture or Tarkhan Gazieyv and Hussein Gakayev. Old guard emirs would have so much to say. Should be an interesting summer and fall. Spring was certainly very bad for the Wahabbis the world over.
VINEYARDSAKER, you forgot to mention the death of Supyan Abdullayev, Doku Umarov’s deputy in late March, the same strike that almost killed Umarov himself. This whole new offensive did not start this year of course. It started with the meticulous operation of June of last year in 2010, when FSB troops captured Akhmed Yevloyev, a.k.a Emir Magas, the over all military emir of the Caucasus Emirate. Doku Umarov may be the Emir, but Magas was the military chief. And from what I can gather a former Police Officer for the Interior Ministry of Ingushetia in the 1990’s. Not just another thugh with a uniform. He also orhstrated the highly successful Nazran raid of 2004. In any case the capture of Magas alive has most likely given the Russians a treasure trove of intelligence on the Emirate’s military infrastructure/apparatus. Muhannad was Magas’ deputy he probably got betrayed by Magas under duress. The overall military emir would also have a good knowledge of safe houses, auxilary support personnel and hideouts in the forests. What they need to do now is go on the hunt again for another capture, not just kills. Aslanbek Vadalov would be a great capture or Tarkhan Gazieyv and Hussein Gakayev. Old guard emirs would have so much to say. Should be an interesting summer and fall. Spring was certainly very bad for the Wahabbis the world over.
and now in 2015 we have this incredible video https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Irj_4IVLBP8